Skip to main content

Principle of Symmetry (Quick Note)

Pick n random points on the line (0, 1). This creates n+1 segments on the line. What is the distribution of length of the k-th segment?

Journey:
1. Try solving for the first segment.
2. Argue that the last segment has the same distribution as the first segment, by symmetry.
3. Surprise: the distribution is the same for all segments. Way to see this: instead of line, think of a circle, and argue by symmetry.


The interesting things to note:
Sometimes we can solve for simpler / extremal case, and then extend it to other cases by symmetry argument.


Application
How many cards on average need to be drawn from the deck to get an Ace?

The short answer:
Mark the top of the deck with a Joker card and arrange them in a circle. The 4As + Joker forms 5 segments on the circle. By symmetry, the length of the segments follow the same distribution and have the same average. The averages must add up to 53. So answer is 53/5.

The long answer, if we don't realise the symmetry:
Let F(t) be the probability of having to draw at least t cards from the deck before getting an Ace. Then F(t) = C(53-t, 4) / C(52, 4).

Let f(t) be the probability of having to draw exactly t cards. Then f(t) = F(t) - F(t+1).

Add t*f(t) up and telescoping we will get the answer C(53, 5)/C(52, 4) = 53/5.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

641 | 2^32 + 1

Problem: Show that \( 641 | 2^{32} + 1 \). Solution: (From Problem Solving Strategies, Arthur Engel) \( 641 = 625 + 16 = 5^4 + 2^4 \). So \( 641 | 2^{32} + 2^{28} \cdot 5^4 \). Also, \( 641 = 640 + 1 = 2^7 \cdot 5 + 1\). So \( 641 | (2^7 \cdot 5)^4 - 1 = 2^{28}\cdot 5^4 - 1 \). Hence \( 641 | 2^{32} + 2^{28} \cdot 5^4 -(2^{28}\cdot 5^4 - 1) \). QED
Post a Comment
Read more

2n+1 3n+1 squares then 5n+3 not prime

Problem: Prove that if \( 2n+1 \) and \( 3n+1 \) are both squares, then \( 5n+3 \) is not a prime. Solution: Proof by contradiction. Suppose that there is n such that 5n+3 is prime. Note that \( 4(2n+1) - (3n+1) = 5n+3 \). Let \( 2n+1 = p^2 \) and \( 3n+1 = q^2 \), where \( p, q > 0 \). We have \( (2p-q)(2p+q) = 5n+3 \). Since RHS is a prime, we must have \(2p - q = 1 \) and \( 2p + q = 5n+3 \). Solving for \( q \) we get \( 2q = 5n + 2 \). Substituting, we get \( 2q = q^2 + 2n + 1 \), or \( -2n = (q-1)^2 \). Since RHS is \( \geq 0 \), we can only have equality when \( n= 0 \) and \( q = 1 \). In this case, we have \( 5n + 3 = 8 \) not a prime. QED.
Post a Comment
Read more

12 coins

Problem: There are 12 identical coins. There might be one that is a counterfeit, which is either heavier or lighter than the rest. Can you identify the counterfeit (if any) using a balance at most 3 times? Solution: I think this is one of the most difficult variations of the coins weighing problem. The main idea is to "mark" the coins after weighing them. Step 1. Divide the coins into groups of 4. Weigh the first two. If they have the same weight, go to step 4. Otherwise, mark the coins belonging to the heavier group 'H', lighter group 'L', and the unweighted ones 'S'. We know that the counterfeit is either in L or H. Step 2. Now we have 4 Hs, 4 Ls, and 4 Ss. We now form 3 groups: HHL, LLH, and HLS. Step 3. Weigh HHL against HLS. Case 3.1: HHL is lighter than HLS. Then either the L in HHL or the H in HLS is the counterfeit. Simply weigh one of them against S and conclude accordingly. Case 3.2: HHL is heavier than HLS. Then the counterfeit ...
Post a Comment
Read more